Difference between revisions of "Do We Need This (song)"
m (Not a b-side, wrt Category talk:B Sides#Dead Star and In Your World) |
m (→Description) |
||
| (11 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Songbox | {{Songbox | ||
| Name = Do We Need This | | Name = Do We Need This? | ||
| Album = [[Uno (single) |Uno<small> CD2</small>]] <small>(3),</small> [[Muscle Museum (single) |Muscle Museum<small> CD1</small>]] <small>(2),</small> [[Random 1-8 (EP)| Random 1-8]] <small>(8)</small>, [[1997 demo (demo) |1997 demo]] <small>(1)</small> | | Album = [[Uno (single) |Uno<small> CD2</small>]] <small>(3),</small> [[Muscle Museum (single) |Muscle Museum<small> CD1</small>]] <small>(2),</small> [[Random 1-8 (EP)| Random 1-8]] <small>(8)</small>, [[1997 demo (demo) |1997 demo]] <small>(1)</small> | ||
| Length = 4:18 | | Length = 4:18 | ||
| AltTitles = | | AltTitles = ''Do We Need This'' | ||
| First = ≤[[Plymouth Hoe 1997 (gig) |1997]] | | First = ≤[[Plymouth Hoe 1997 (gig) |1997]] | ||
| Latest = [[Rouen Exo 7 2000 (gig) | | | Latest = [[Rouen Exo 7 2000 (gig) |8th January 2000]] | ||
| Recorded = 1997 <small>([[1997 demo (demo) |1997 demo]])</small>, 1999 <small>([[Showbiz (album) |Showbiz]])</small> | | Recorded = 1997 <small>([[1997 demo (demo) |1997 demo]])</small>, 1999 <small>([[Showbiz (album) |Showbiz]])</small> | ||
| Writer = [[Matthew Bellamy]] | | Writer = [[Matthew Bellamy]] | ||
| Line 11: | Line 11: | ||
| Chart position = - | | Chart position = - | ||
}} | }} | ||
'''[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ukPiRjxWjoo Listen]''' | |||
== Description == | == Description == | ||
Very creepy with an emphasis on eerily simple piano and percussion at the beginning which then morphs into the usual epic rock number with a simple 3 chord power riff. | |||
== Additional information == | == Additional information == | ||
It appears to be about perfectionism and the whole "Showbiz" theme: putting on a persona that doesn't reflect the persons true inner self.< | It appears to be about perfectionism and the whole "Showbiz" theme: putting on a persona that doesn't reflect the persons true inner self. Matt believed it to be the best Muse song around July 1999, and when a fan asked why it wasn't on the album, he claimed it would be on the next album. Perhaps the band were saving it for the second album before deciding against it at some point after the release of Showbiz.<ref>[https://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/instantMUSEnger/conversations/messages/327]</ref> This may not be the case, however, as Matt revealed during the first discussion about Muscle Museum's release that Do We Need This was intended to be an Uno b-side, and he addressed the song as "bad".<ref>[https://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/instantMUSEnger/conversations/topics/1202]</ref> | ||
[[Thomas Kirk]] played some percussion. | [[Thomas Kirk]] played some percussion. | ||
| Line 22: | Line 24: | ||
== Music trivia == | == Music trivia == | ||
At 2:23, 2:31, 2:35, 2:38 and 2:43, there is a scratching sound, like a zip. | At 2:23, 2:31, 2:35, 2:38 and 2:43, there is a scratching sound, like a zip. | ||
The part starting at 2:49 sounds almost identical to "Freedom" by "Rage Against The Machine" (the riff at 1:44). | |||
== Live == | |||
Most likely due to a lack of tracks to play at larger gigs, the song was played very often between April and August 1999. Do We Need This typically acted as the outro song or the second last to be played during these gigs. After August and with the exception of [[Paris MCM Café 1999 (gig) |the November 10th gig]] the song was mostly left out of setlists. It made a few appearances in January 2000 as well as unconfirmed performances in February before being dropped. | |||
[[Do We Need This (live) | More here]] | |||
== Lyrics == | == Lyrics == | ||
| Line 52: | Line 60: | ||
}} | }} | ||
=== Random 1-8 === | === Random 1-8 (Amsterdam Paradiso 2000)=== | ||
{{lyrics | {{lyrics | ||
|Too many people trapped in your mould | |Too many people trapped in your mould | ||
| Line 58: | Line 66: | ||
Is sung instead of the second line of the chorus. | Is sung instead of the second line of the chorus. | ||
== References == | |||
<References/> | |||
== See also == | == See also == | ||
| Line 63: | Line 74: | ||
{{Backto | Uno (single) | Uno CD2}} | {{Backto | Uno (single) | Uno CD2}} | ||
[[Category:B Sides]] | |||
Latest revision as of 01:34, 3 September 2023
| Muse song | |
|---|---|
| Name | Do We Need This? |
| Album/single | Uno CD2 (3), Muscle Museum CD1 (2), Random 1-8 (8), 1997 demo (1) |
| Length | 4:18 |
| Alternative titles | Do We Need This |
| First live performance | ≤1997 |
| Latest live performance | 8th January 2000 |
| Recorded | 1997 (1997 demo), 1999 (Showbiz) |
| Writer/composer | Matthew Bellamy |
| Producer | Paul Reeve |
Description
Very creepy with an emphasis on eerily simple piano and percussion at the beginning which then morphs into the usual epic rock number with a simple 3 chord power riff.
Additional information
It appears to be about perfectionism and the whole "Showbiz" theme: putting on a persona that doesn't reflect the persons true inner self. Matt believed it to be the best Muse song around July 1999, and when a fan asked why it wasn't on the album, he claimed it would be on the next album. Perhaps the band were saving it for the second album before deciding against it at some point after the release of Showbiz.[1] This may not be the case, however, as Matt revealed during the first discussion about Muscle Museum's release that Do We Need This was intended to be an Uno b-side, and he addressed the song as "bad".[2]
Thomas Kirk played some percussion.
Music trivia
At 2:23, 2:31, 2:35, 2:38 and 2:43, there is a scratching sound, like a zip. The part starting at 2:49 sounds almost identical to "Freedom" by "Rage Against The Machine" (the riff at 1:44).
Live
Most likely due to a lack of tracks to play at larger gigs, the song was played very often between April and August 1999. Do We Need This typically acted as the outro song or the second last to be played during these gigs. After August and with the exception of the November 10th gig the song was mostly left out of setlists. It made a few appearances in January 2000 as well as unconfirmed performances in February before being dropped.
Lyrics
Too many young and too many old
Too many people left you in the cold You want everything to change 'cause you are afraid of losing
She only exists when she's on a screen He's only alive inside a machine We want everything to change 'cause you are afraid of losing
Tell me do you really need this Tell me do you really care Tell me do you really need this Tell me do you really care
'cause I don't think you really need this I don't think you really care I don't think you really need this I don't think you really care
Too many young and too many old Too many people left in the cold We want everything to change Now I'm so afraid of losing Yeah yeah yeah
Random 1-8 (Amsterdam Paradiso 2000)
Too many people trapped in your mould
Is sung instead of the second line of the chorus.